Analysis of willa cather s paul s case like it or not, humans tend to receive influences from their surroundings. Pauls case the short story essay 932 words 4 pages. Pauls lack of maternal care has led to his alienation. Analysis of pauls case by willa cather willa cathers pauls case is a story about a young 16 yearold man, paul, who is motherless and alienated.
Curricular indicators satisfied by a unit devoted to pauls case chief learning objectives. To relate the work to oneself and to the larger culture. Theme paul s actions society can prevent people from reaching the american dream by not accepting their differences and alienating them. However, paul feels that he should belong to the bourgeoisie the upper, ruling class. Pauls case, written by willa cather, tells the story of paul, a young man who is always in search of something more in his life. He had been suspended a week ago, and his father had called at the principals office and confessed his perplexity about his son. Essentially, it is about a young man, sixteen years of age, best described as an alien as a result of being motherless. This study guide for willa cather s paul s case offers summary and analysis on themes, symbols, and other literary devices found in the text. This is a quick summary of pauls case by willa cather. Paul s case the short story essay 932 words 4 pages. Essay analysis of willa cather s paul s case like it or not, humans tend to receive influences from their surroundings. The protagonist is a sensitive highschool student who despises his middleclass home and. See a complete list of the characters in pauls case.
A constant nuisance to his teachers, paul belittles the world around him with a sort of arrogance. Willa cather s short story paul s case was published in 1905 and follows the titular paul over the course of a few months. It recounts the tragic results of a boys desire to escape what he sees as a dull and stifling environment the protagonist is a sensitive highschool student who despises his middleclass home and family and sees the art world as a glamorous alternative to that life. An analysis of pauls case by willa cather 296 words 123. Just like freuds dora became the typical example of a hysterical woman, we can take paul to be the typical example of.
Jan 07, 2017 in pauls case by willa cather we have the theme of hostility, respect, freedom, escape, corruption, determination and commitment. Willa cathers pauls case is a good example of a work adapted to video. In pauls case by willa cather we have the theme of hostility, respect, freedom, escape, corruption, determination and commitment. A while later, following the boasting incidence about carnegie halls stock crew, the faculty and pauls father, along with the members of carnegie hall, concurred that pauls case was a bad one. Theme pauls actions society can prevent people from reaching the american dream by not accepting their differences and alienating them. Willa cather seems to base her stories off of daily life and events that she thought progressed in. The story begins with paul s faculty hearing one week after he has been suspended from school. Paul may seem like the typical juvenile delinquent whose only motivations in life are to mock and annoy others to get the attention he so desires. Paul, pauls father, charley edwards, the soprano, the drawing master, the english teacher, the young clerk, the yale student. Paul was a misfit and was unable to accept the drab reality of his daily life. Pauls case quotes showing 15 of 5 he was entirely rid of his nervous misgivings, of his forced aggressiveness, of the imperative desire to show himself different from his surroundings.
Willa cathers short story pauls case was published in 1905 and follows the titular paul over the course of a few months. That year, it also appeared in a collection of cathers stories, the troll garden. The movie has slight differences from the book, but the director lamont johnson follows the original closely. It recounts as if all took place just yesterday, but in fact, it was published in 1905. Pdf paulscasethemeanalysis lilly bektemirova academia. It was paul s afternoon to appear before the faculty of the pittsburgh high school to account for his various misdemeanors. It was first published in mcclure s magazine in 1905 under the title paul s case.
Irony and symbolism in pauls case by willa cather 1788. Analysis of pauls case by willa cather essay 2549 words 11 pages. Although he is often playful, performative, and defiant, he is privately quite depressed. However, the subtitle, a study in temperament, suggests a more neutral or even sympathetic perspectivethe exploration of an individuals unique sensibilities. A study in temperament is a short story by willa cather that was first published in 1905. It is a testimony to the reality of youthful dissatisfactions and the common failure of families to understand and of schools to be helpful. A study in temperament was published in cathers short story collection, the troll garden in 1905 a study in temperament. Symbolism of paul in pauls case english literature essay. Wilson, and his cousin, harold orr, had stolen money from wilson s employer. The plot begins with the exposition, which is pauls failure to pay attention and rebellious acts.
Analysis of pauls case pauls case, by willa cather tells the story of a young boy who is disillusioned by his suburban lifestyle. According to many readers of pauls case, this is a short story that shows affection, passion, and most of all enthusiasm. For many years paul s case was the only one of her stories that cather allowed to be. It was pauls afternoon to appear before the faculty of the pittsburgh high school to account for his various misdemeanors. Understanding and interpreting willa ather s pauls case. Pauls case was written in the context of a number of literary movements at the turn of the twentieth century, but naturalismwhich sought to portray everyday life realistically while also study the effect of environment on individual characterswas particularly thriving. Symbolism in pauls case renee carpenterhoude opaulos case,o published in 1905 by willa cather, tells the story of a depressed young man named paul whose feelings of superiority and desire for the. Paul shrugged his shoulders slightly and his eyebrows twitched. The alienation actually sent paul out to go and look for some aesthetics given their absence from his yellow wallpaper.
Her short story, paul s case, tells about a young man who does not feel he belongs in his home town. It recounts the tragic results of a boys desire to escape what he sees as a dull and stifling environment. For many years pauls case was the only one of her stories that cather allowed to be anthologized. Pauls case is useful in student discussions of adolescent issues and adolescent suicide.
The character of paul in pauls case from litcharts the. Critical analysis of pauls case essay example graduateway. As the inquisition proceeded, one of his instructors repeated an impertinent remark of the boys, and the principal asked him whether he thought that a courteous speech to have made a woman. In pauls case, willa cather uses symbolism along with a theatrical structure to illustrate the life of a young man who lives his life as though it were a play. Irony and symbolism in willa cathers pauls case essay cram. It also appeared in a collection of cathers stories, the troll garden 1905.
The pauls case community note includes chapterbychapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography. Cather would agree that music and art are fundamentally problematic when used as escapes from our problems. He stood through it, smiling, his pale lips parted over his white teeth. This study guide for willa cathers pauls case offers summary and analysis on themes, symbols, and other literary devices found in the text. It also appeared in a collection of cather s stories, the troll garden 1905. As the inquisition proceeded, one of his instructors repeated an impertinent remark of the boy s, and the principal asked him whether he thought that a courteous speech to have made a woman.
A study in temperament and indepth analyses of paul. Mar 26, 2015 wiila cather was a pulitzer prizewinning american author. Pauls case study guide from litcharts the creators of. Pauls case his teachers felt, this afternoon, that hiswilla cather whole attitude was symbolized by his shrug and his flippantly red carnation flower, and they fell upon i him without mercy. The newspaper reported that wilson had a longing to know how it would feel to have enough money to have just as. Curricular indicators satisfied by a unit devoted to pauls. Paul is a student at pittsburgh high school, who would rather be at the opera than in class, and has romantic, misguided notions of reality. To understand how literary texts interact with their cultural contexts.
Pauls case character analysis by ellie strang on prezi. Pauls case question answers case solution, analysis. It was first published in mcclures magazine in 1905 under the title pauls case. Her short story, pauls case, tells about a young man who does not feel he belongs in his home town. This study guide consists of approximately 44 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of paul s case. Analysis of pauls case by willa cather 1076 words 5 pages. Pauls case is a short story and probably not as famous as some of willa cathers other writings, but it stuck out to me because i could understand the character and his rebellious nature against the society that was trying to force him do things that. Heres where youll find analysis of the story as a whole. The title pauls case suggests the story of a misfit who, by the standards of society, needs to be reformed. Technically we should classify the authors point of view as omniscient, for she enters into the minds of characters at will. A study in temperament, cather is saying not only that this is a pretty interesting dude even if hes also pretty annoying, but also that we can use this study to understand people like paul. The pauls case community note includes chapterbychapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and quizzes written by community members like you. A study in temperament lyrics i he had been suspended a week ago, and his father had called at the principals office and confessed his perplexity about his son.
Critical analysis pauls case was not, by any means, my favorite short movie. Paul s case his teachers felt, this afternoon, that hiswilla cather whole attitude was symbolized by his shrug and his flippantly red carnation flower, and they fell upon i him without mercy. Paul s case is useful in student discussions of adolescent issues and adolescent suicide. A study in temperament is, like the title implies, an analysis of a particular individual whose unique nature makes him worthy of exploration. Pauls case is one of the short stories written by willa cather. A study in temperament is a short story by willa cather, first published in mcclures magazine in 1905.
Throughout pauls case, paul is treated as the proletariat the lower, working class by his father, teachers, and employers. Pauls effort to prove that he is better than his classmates and teachers winds up alienating him from them. This analysis of pauls case is by sarah wyman, associate professor of english at sunynew paltz. The lack of a diagnosis for paul has led many critics to develop their own diagnosis. The dsmiv states that the essential features of a narcissistic personality disorder are a. Taken from her the troll garden collection the story is narrated in the third person by an unnamed narrator and from the beginning of the story the reader realises that cather may be exploring the theme of hostility. One afternoon, all his teachers at pittsburgh high school met together with him to discuss his case.
Paul s case makes a case for the importance of art and music education in schools. Curricular indicators satisfied by a unit devoted to paul. It was paul s afternoon to appear before the faculty of the pittsburg high school to account for his various misdemeanors. Pauls case by willa cather summary minute book report. Tall and thin, with bright, glassy eyes, paul sticks out from his fellow students both in his appearancehe wears dandyish accessories like an opal pin and a red carnation and in his flamboyant demeanor. In the end, the principal speaks with pauls father, and paul is forbidden to return to school, carnegie hall, or the theater where charley edwards works. Pauls case willa cather pages 1 9 text version fliphtml5. Pauls case, the only short story willa cather approved for anthologies, opens with a young boy called before his high school principal and teachers. The theater companys members hear about pauls lies and find them comical.
Pauls case, short story by willa cather, published in the collection the troll garden in 1905. Analysis of pauls case by willa cather essay 1072 words. An analysis of pauls case by willa cather 296 words. The protagonist of cathers story is described in careful physical and behavioral detail. Wiila cather was a pulitzer prizewinning american author. Willa cather s paul s case is a good example of a work adapted to video. Pauls case makes a case for the importance of art and music education in schools. Jun 15, 2015 this is a quick summary of pauls case by willa cather. Willa cather seems to base her stories off of daily life and events that she thought progressed in many lives. This free synopsis covers all the crucial plot points of pauls case. Whether external or internal, influences help people grow and develop as human beings. However, most of the necessary literary elements were present. Willa cathers short story, pauls case, revolves around paul, a boy who seems out of place from everyone else. To learn how to analyze the symbolic meanings of texts.
979 1504 1091 162 1236 206 869 712 1221 372 607 529 479 1609 1657 1500 446 1239 1437 481 270 1202 458 1127 228 1426 1239 1626 1035 1020 1270 526 803 1102 240 341 938 1382 248